Member-only story

Stories of Supreme Court Law Clerks and Their Justices: Constitutionalism and Beyond

Hudson Hayes

·16.8k Followers· Follow

Published in In Chambers: Stories Of Supreme Court Law Clerks And Their Justices (Constitutionalism And Democracy)

6 min read

333 View Claps

19 Respond

Save

Listen

The Supreme Court of the United States stands as the apex of the American judicial system, its decisions shaping the nation's laws and influencing society in countless ways. While the Justices are the public face of the Court, they rely heavily on their law clerks, young legal minds who provide invaluable assistance in the complex process of deciding cases. The relationships between Justices and their clerks are often close and mutually beneficial, and they can have a profound impact on not only the Court's work but also on the personal and professional lives of all involved.

In Chambers: Stories of Supreme Court Law Clerks and Their Justices (Constitutionalism and Democracy)

by Todd C. Peppers

4.8 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	2140 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	472 pages

This article delves into the rich history and fascinating stories of Supreme Court law clerks and their Justices, exploring the ways in which their interactions have shaped American constitutionalism and the broader legal landscape. Drawing on firsthand accounts, historical documents, and expert insights, we will examine the role of law clerks in the decision-making process, their influence on legal scholarship, and the lasting personal bonds that often develop between these two groups of legal professionals.

The Role of Law Clerks in the Decision-Making Process

Law clerks play a vital role in the day-to-day operations of the Supreme Court. They conduct legal research, draft opinions, and assist the Justices in understanding complex legal issues. While they do not have a vote in the Court's decisions, their work can significantly influence the outcome of cases.

One of the most important functions of law clerks is to provide the Justices with a fresh perspective on the cases they are considering. Clerks come from diverse backgrounds and legal experiences, and they bring a range of viewpoints to the decision-making process. This diversity helps to ensure that the Court's decisions are well-informed and reflective of the different perspectives that exist within American society.

In addition to their research and writing responsibilities, law clerks also provide feedback on the Justices' draft opinions. They offer constructive criticism, point out potential legal errors, and suggest alternative approaches to legal reasoning. This feedback can help the Justices to refine their arguments and strengthen their opinions before they are released to the public.

The role of law clerks in the decision-making process has evolved over time. In the early days of the Court, law clerks were primarily responsible for performing administrative tasks. However, as the Court's workload increased and the complexity of the cases it considered grew, the role of law clerks became increasingly important. Today, law clerks are essential members of the Supreme Court team, and they play a vital role in shaping the Court's decisions.

The Influence of Law Clerks on Legal Scholarship

In addition to their work on the Court, law clerks often go on to have successful careers in academia, government, and private practice. Many former law clerks have become leading legal scholars, and their work has had a significant impact on the development of American law.

One of the ways that law clerks influence legal scholarship is through their academic writing. Many former law clerks publish articles in law reviews and other scholarly journals, sharing their insights on the Supreme Court's decisions and offering their own perspectives on legal issues. This scholarship helps to shape the way that legal academics and practitioners think about the law, and it can also influence the Court's own thinking in future cases.

Another way that law clerks influence legal scholarship is through their teaching. Many former law clerks go on to teach at law schools, where they share their knowledge of the Supreme Court with a new generation of law students. This teaching can help to ensure that the Court's decisions are accurately understood and that future lawyers are well-prepared to handle the complex legal issues that they will face in their careers.

The Personal Bonds Between Justices and Law Clerks

While the relationship between Justices and their law clerks is primarily professional, it often develops into a deep personal bond. Justices rely on their law clerks for support and guidance, and law clerks value the mentorship and wisdom of their Justices.

One of the most famous examples of the close relationship between Justices and their law clerks is the relationship between Justice Felix Frankfurter and his law clerk, Alan Dershowitz. Dershowitz clerked for Frankfurter during the 1964-1965 term, and the two men remained close friends until Frankfurter's death in 1965. Dershowitz has written extensively about his experience clerking for Frankfurter, and his writing provides a fascinating glimpse into the personal and intellectual bond that developed between the two men.

Another example of the close relationship between Justices and their law clerks is the relationship between Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and her law clerk, Paul Clement. Clement clerked for Ginsburg during the 1996-1997 term, and the two women remained close friends until Ginsburg's death in 2020. Clement has spoken about his admiration for Ginsburg's intellect and her commitment to justice, and he has said that she was one of the most influential people in his life.

The personal bonds between Justices and their law clerks can have a lasting impact on both the Justices and the clerks. For the Justices, these relationships can provide them with companionship, support, and intellectual stimulation. For the clerks, these relationships can provide them with mentorship, guidance, and a deep understanding of the law.

In Chambers: Stories of Supreme Court Law Clerks and Their Justices (Constitutionalism and Democracy)

by Todd C. Peppers

4.8 out of 5